EverydayArticle link

Saying yes to unusual behaviors to reduce conflict

Key points

  • Unusual behaviors like hoarding or layering are often the person's way of communicating an unmet need or coping with brain changes—not deliberate defiance.
  • Always assess the behavior for safety first. If it's harmless, consider letting it go to reduce conflict and preserve the relationship.
  • Use validation and redirection instead of confrontation. Phrases like 'I see you're cold, let's find a soft sweater' can work wonders.
  • Create a 'safe hoard' box or drawer to give the person a sense of control while containing clutter.
  • Establish a calm nightly routine to check for hidden hazards without shaming the person.
  • Adapt your approach based on the stage of dementia, the care setting, and your relationship with the person. Support groups and professional guidance can help.

General caregiving information, not medical advice. Check medications and major care changes with your clinician.

Step-by-step

  1. Step 1: Pause and assess the behavior's risk. Ask yourself: Is this behavior causing immediate physical harm (e.g., tripping over clutter, overheating from layers)? Is it creating a health hazard (e.g., spoiled food, insect infestation)? If the answer is no, consider letting it go for now. If yes, proceed to step 2 with a calm, non-confrontational approach.

  2. Step 2: Validate their experience before redirecting. Use phrases like, 'I see you're collecting these tissues. They must be important to you,' or 'You must be feeling cold today. Let's find a way to keep you warm and comfortable.' Validation lowers their defenses and opens the door to cooperation.

  3. Step 3: Use distraction to interrupt the behavioral loop. If they are fixated on leaving the house or hoarding a dangerous item, redirect to a different activity. For example, say, 'Let's have a cup of tea first, then we can look at that together,' or 'I need your help folding these towels. Can you show me how?' This technique, often called 'the art of the maybe,' buys time and shifts their focus (source 13).

  4. Step 4: Offer acceptable substitutions. If they want to wear multiple layers, help them choose lightweight, breathable fabrics that still provide warmth. If they are hoarding, provide a designated 'safe' box or drawer where they can keep a few treasured items, and gently remove the rest when they are not looking. As one expert suggests, think of 'substitutions'—what could I do instead that meets the same need? (source 5).

  5. Step 5: Simplify the environment to reduce triggers. Remove clutter from common areas to minimize opportunities for hoarding. Use safety gates at the top of stairs if pacing is a concern (source 2). Keep medications and dangerous items locked away. A clutter-free space helps manage these behaviors more effectively (source 21).

  6. Step 6: Establish a routine for checking and managing clutter. At the end of each day, do a quick sweep of their room or living area. Check pockets, drawers, and under furniture for hidden food, tissues, or other items that could spoil or become a hazard. Do this calmly and without judgment, framing it as 'tidying up together.'

  7. Step 7: Use positive reinforcement and humor. When they cooperate or allow you to remove an item, offer genuine praise: 'Thank you for helping me keep things safe.' Some support groups even use playful tools like wearing a tutu while discarding items to lift the mood (source 7). A lighthearted approach can make the process less stressful for both of you.

  8. Step 8: Reflect and regroup after a difficult interaction. If a conflict does arise, take a moment afterward to think about what triggered it. Was it the time of day? Your tone? The environment? Use this insight to adjust your approach next time. As one expert advises, 'take time to think through that interaction... to see if there was something wrong with them, something wrong with me, or something in the environment that I need to fix' (source 12).

What not to do

  • Do not confront or argue about the behavior. Confrontation often escalates agitation because the person cannot reflect on their actions or control them. Instead, use a calm tone and redirect. As one source warns, 'don't confront somebody and whatever you do don't initiate physical contact during an outburst because that's going to escalate it' (source 24).

  • Do not try to 'fix' the behavior overnight. Hoarding or layering habits may take time to shift. Pushing too hard can lead to resistance and erode trust. Focus on small, consistent steps rather than demanding immediate change.

  • Do not take the behavior personally. The person is not doing this to annoy you. Their actions are driven by brain changes and unmet needs. Remind yourself: 'They are doing the very best they can to communicate' (source 14). This mindset shift can reduce your own frustration.

  • Do not ignore safety risks in the name of reducing conflict. While it is wise to let go of minor quirks, you must intervene if there is a risk of falls, poisoning, or fire. Lock up dangerous items, secure sharp objects, and remove clutter from pathways. Safety always comes first (source 22).

  • Do not use guilt or shame to stop the behavior. Statements like 'Why are you doing this? It's so messy!' only increase their distress and may deepen the behavior. Instead, use neutral, supportive language that focuses on solutions, not blame.

Practical tools

  • The 'Yes, And' Phrase Bank

    Keep these phrases ready: 'I see you're collecting these. Let's put them in this special box together.' 'You must be cold. Let's find a soft sweater that fits well.' 'I need your help with something first, then we can look at that.' These phrases validate the person's reality while gently guiding them toward a safer or more manageable alternative.

  • The 'Safe Hoard' Box or Drawer

    Designate a single drawer, box, or shelf where your loved one can keep items they collect—tissues, magazines, trinkets. This gives them a sense of control and ownership while containing the clutter. Check it weekly to remove anything spoiled or hazardous, but do so when they are not present to avoid conflict.

  • Layered Clothing Checklist for Safety

    If your loved one insists on wearing multiple layers, use this checklist: Are they able to move freely? Are they sweating or showing signs of overheating? Are the layers clean and dry? Can they use the bathroom independently? If any answer is no, offer a substitution like a lightweight fleece or a shawl instead of a heavy coat indoors.

  • The 'Evening Sweep' Routine

    Each evening, do a calm, 5-minute sweep of their living space. Check for hidden food, sharp objects, or items that could cause falls. Frame it as 'Let's make sure everything is tidy for tomorrow.' This prevents hazards from accumulating without making the person feel criticized.

  • Distraction Activity Cards

    Create a small set of cards or a list of go-to activities that can redirect your loved one when they are fixated on a behavior. Examples: 'Look at this photo album,' 'Let's fold napkins together,' 'Can you help me water the plant?' Having these ready reduces your stress in the moment.

  • The 'Time Out' for Both of You

    If a conflict escalates, step away for a few minutes. Say, 'I need to get a drink of water. I'll be right back.' This gives both of you a chance to cool down. Return with a different approach—a snack, soft music, or a change of topic. As one expert advises, 'give her a time out... and come back in a few minutes and try again but have a different approach' (source 4).

Discuss with your clinician

If your loved one's hoarding includes collecting sharp objects, medications, or other dangerous items, discuss with their doctor or a social worker about harm reduction strategies and possible need for a home safety assessment.

If the person is wearing so many layers that they are at risk of overheating, dehydration, or falls, consult their healthcare provider to rule out underlying medical issues like infection or pain that may be driving the behavior.

If the behavior is accompanied by aggression, paranoia, or significant distress, discuss with a geriatric psychiatrist or neurologist whether medication adjustments or behavioral interventions might help.

If hoarding leads to unsanitary conditions (e.g., spoiled food, insect infestation) that threaten the person's health, talk to a case manager about options for professional cleaning services or adult protective services involvement.

Related guides

Sources