Use careArticle link

Vetting a home care company for a dementia patient

Key points

  • Always verify an agency’s legitimacy: ask for proof of workers’ comp, liability insurance, bonding, and nationwide background checks.
  • Interview at least three agencies and do an in-home interview with a third person present to compare impressions.
  • Ask specific scenario-based questions to test the caregiver’s dementia training, not just general senior care experience.
  • Check references from other families caring for someone with dementia, not just general clients.
  • Start with a trial period and keep a log of observations for the first month to catch any red flags early.
  • Use local resources like the Area Agency on Aging, Alzheimer’s Association, and Home Care Association of America to find vetted agencies.

General caregiving information, not medical advice. Check medications and major care changes with your clinician.

Step-by-step

  1. Find agencies through trusted sources: local Area Agency on Aging or state department on aging (ask about PACE programs and respite vouchers), local Alzheimer's Association chapter, and the Home Care Association of America's website (members are W-2 employers with workers' comp, thorough background checks, and 24/7 coverage).

  2. Prepare a one-page summary before calling agencies: loved one's name, physician's name/number, diagnoses (e.g., Alzheimer's, vascular dementia), other health needs (e.g., diabetes, fall risk), behavioral issues (e.g., wandering, agitation), insurance coverage, and personal preferences (e.g., likes music, dislikes being rushed at meals).

  3. Phone-screen at least three agencies asking: 'What specialized dementia training do caregivers receive? Do you run nationwide criminal background checks? Are caregivers bonded and for what amount? What is the backup plan if a caregiver calls in sick? Do you have 24/7 phone support? What are minimum hours and rates?' Vague answers are red flags.

  4. Schedule in-home interviews with top two agencies. Meet the specific caregiver assigned. Watch how they address your loved one, and ask scenario questions like 'How would you handle Mom insisting she needs to go to the store at 10 p.m.?' A good answer uses redirection and validation, not arguing.

  5. Verify agency legitimacy: call three client references (dementia families preferred); ask to see proof of workers' comp, general liability insurance, bonding amount, business license, and a sample background check (nationwide and motor vehicle); request latest inspection report if licensed; and make an unannounced office visit if possible.

  6. Request a 2-3 day trial period before committing. Observe your loved one's mood and whether the caregiver communicates daily. Trust your gut and switch agencies if something feels off.

  7. Keep a log for the first weeks noting missing items, behavior changes, or punctuality/attitude concerns. If your loved one accuses the caregiver of stealing, search the home thoroughly first—dementia often causes misplacing items—but report any patterns to the agency immediately.

What not to do

  • Don't hire the first agency without comparing at least three; take a week to research even if desperate.

  • Don't rely solely on online reviews—agencies may fake them. Verify with references and your own observations.

  • Don't accept county-only background checks. Require nationwide criminal and motor vehicle searches; treat refusal as a dealbreaker.

  • Don't assume general senior care experience equals dementia care. Specialized skills like redirection, validation, and managing sundowning are essential.

  • Don't dismiss your loved one's discomfort with a caregiver, even if unarticulated—their instincts may catch what you miss.

  • Don't sign a long-term contract without a trial period. Negotiate a 30-day trial with a 7-day cancellation clause; if refused, find another agency.

Practical tools

  • Agency Legitimacy Checklist

    Before hiring, ask for and verify: (1) workers' compensation insurance, (2) general liability insurance, (3) bonding amount, (4) business license, (5) sample caregiver background check (redacted) showing nationwide criminal and motor vehicle search. Say: 'I need these to protect my family. Can you email them?' If they refuse, move on.

  • Dementia Scenario Interview Cards

    Print 3-5 scenarios to ask during interviews: (1) 'Mom thinks it's 1965 and wants to pick up her kids. What do you do?' (2) 'Dad is agitated accusing you of stealing his wallet. How do you respond?' (3) 'Mom refuses a shower and becomes combative. Walk me through your approach.' Good answers use redirection, validation, calm tone—never arguing or forcing.

  • One-Page Loved One Summary

    Single sheet sent to each agency before first call: name, physician name/number, primary/secondary diagnoses, other health needs (e.g., diabetes, fall risk), behavioral issues (e.g., wandering, sundowning), insurance coverage, and personal preferences (e.g., favorite music, disliked foods, routines). Specificity helps match a caregiver with relevant dementia experience.

Discuss with your clinician

Ask your loved one’s doctor: ‘Given their specific diagnosis and stage, what are the most important skills a home caregiver should have? Are there any behaviors (like wandering or aggression) that require special training?’

If the agency offers medication management (e.g., reminding or administering pills), ask your clinician: ‘Is it safe for a non-medical caregiver to handle my loved one’s medications? Should we use a pill dispenser or a pharmacy service instead?’

If your loved one has a history of falls, ask the doctor: ‘What specific safety measures should the caregiver be trained in? Should we get a medical alert system or bed alarm?’

If you are considering a home care agency that also provides skilled nursing (e.g., wound care, injections), ask your clinician: ‘Do you recommend this agency? Are their nurses licensed and experienced with dementia patients?’

If your loved one has behavioral issues like aggression or psychosis, ask the doctor: ‘Should we have a behavior management plan in place before hiring a caregiver? Are there any medications that might help, and how should the caregiver be trained to monitor side effects?’

Related guides

Sources