EverydayArticle link

The two-choice technique (offering only two options)

Key points

  • Offer only two options that you are okay with—never a choice you cannot deliver.
  • Use simple, short phrases and, if possible, show the two items visually.
  • Wait patiently for a response; do not rush or add more options.
  • Affirm their choice with a positive statement to reinforce their sense of control.
  • If they refuse both, step back and try again later with the same or slightly different options.
  • This technique works for many daily decisions: food, clothing, activities, and timing of tasks.

General caregiving information, not medical advice. Check medications and major care changes with your clinician.

Step-by-step

  1. Before you ask, decide on two options that you are genuinely okay with. For example, if you are offering lunch, choose two things you have on hand and are willing to prepare—like 'turkey sandwich or grilled cheese?' Do not offer something you cannot or will not deliver.

  2. Use simple, clear language. Say: 'Would you like the red shirt or the blue shirt?' or 'Would you like soup or pasta for lunch?' Keep the sentence short—no more than 10 words if possible.

  3. If you can, add a visual cue. Hold up the two items as you name them. For example, hold out a can of tuna and a slice of ham and say, 'Which would you like?' This helps the person see what you mean, reducing confusion.

  4. Wait patiently for a response. Give them at least 10 seconds of quiet. Do not repeat the question or add more options. If they seem stuck, gently repeat the two choices once more, then wait again.

  5. If they do not choose, you can make a gentle suggestion: 'How about we try the turkey sandwich? We can always have the grilled cheese tomorrow.' This uses the 'let's try' approach, which gives permission to try without pressure.

  6. Once they choose, affirm their decision with a positive, simple statement: 'Great choice! I'll make that now.' This reinforces their sense of control and success.

  7. If they refuse both options, do not argue. Instead, say, 'Okay, no problem. Let's try again later.' Then step away and revisit the decision in a few minutes with the same two options or slightly different ones.

  8. Use this technique for any decision: what to wear, what activity to do, when to bathe, what to drink. The same structure works across many situations.

What not to do

  • Do not ask open-ended questions like 'What do you want for lunch?' This forces the person to scan too many possibilities and often leads to a request you cannot fulfill, setting up an argument. Instead, offer two specific options you can provide.

  • Do not offer more than two choices. Even three can be overwhelming. Stick to two to keep the decision manageable.

  • Do not use logic or reasoning to convince them. For example, do not say 'You need a coat because it's cold outside.' Their brain may not process that reasoning. Instead, just bring the coat and offer two coat options, or simply hand it to them when they go out.

  • Do not correct them if they choose something you think is 'wrong' (e.g., wearing a summer shirt in winter). If it is safe, let them choose. You can always bring a sweater along. The goal is to preserve their autonomy, not to be right.

  • Do not rush them. Giving them time to process is essential. If you fill the silence with more words, you increase their confusion.

  • Do not use the technique for every single decision. Some things are non-negotiable (e.g., medication). Save the two-choice approach for situations where you can genuinely offer flexibility.

Practical tools

  • The 'Two-Option Menu' Phrase Bank

    Keep a mental or written list of common two-choice phrases for daily decisions: 'Would you like the blue towel or the green towel?', 'Would you like soup or pasta for lunch?', 'Would you like to do laundry now or after breakfast?', 'Would you like the red shirt or the white shirt?', 'Would you like cookies or a fruit bowl for dessert?' These are simple, clear, and easy to say.

  • Visual Choice Cards

    Create or buy simple picture cards for common options: two types of food, two clothing items, two activities. Hold up the two cards as you ask. This reduces the need for verbal processing and can be especially helpful in middle or later stages.

  • The 'Let's Try' Script

    When the person is hesitant, use this script: 'Let's just try the turkey sandwich. If you don't like it, that's okay.' The word 'try' gives permission to not like it, reducing pressure. This is especially useful for tasks the person may resist, like bathing or changing clothes.

  • Daily Choice Chart

    Create a simple paper chart with two columns: 'Breakfast' and 'Lunch' (or 'Morning' and 'Afternoon'). Each day, write or check off two options for each meal. The person can point or check the box. This also helps them remember what they chose and reduces confusion about time of day.

  • Environment Setup: Two Visible Items

    When offering a choice, physically place the two options in front of the person. For example, put two shirts on the bed, or two bowls of soup on the table. This makes the choice concrete and visual, reducing the need for abstract thinking.

  • The 'Reflect and Offer' Technique

    When the person asks a question like 'Have you seen my mom?', instead of correcting them, reflect back and then offer two choices: 'I know you're thinking of your mom. Would you like to look at a photo album or take a walk?' This redirects without confrontation.

Discuss with your clinician

If the person consistently refuses both options and becomes agitated, discuss with their doctor whether there may be an underlying medical issue (e.g., pain, infection, medication side effect) that is affecting their ability to engage.

If the person is on medications that affect cognition (e.g., antipsychotics, sedatives), ask the clinician how these might impact their decision-making ability and whether the two-choice technique is appropriate at certain times of day.

If the person has a history of severe anxiety or depression, ask the clinician for additional strategies to use alongside the two-choice technique, as emotional distress can block even simple choices.

Related guides

Sources