EverydayArticle link

Redirecting Grabs: What to Offer Instead of Taking Away

When your loved one grabs at objects, people, or even your hands, it's rarely 'bad behavior' — it's a brain-driven impulse to explore, soothe, or communicate an unmet need. In the amber GEMS state, the person is drawn to what they see and may not fully understand that the item belongs to someone else or is unsafe. Instead of pulling things away (which can trigger distress or aggression), you can offer a safe, appealing substitute. This article gives you concrete steps, phrases to say, and tools to make substitution work — so you both feel calmer and more connected.

Key points

  • Grabbing is a brain-driven impulse, not bad behavior — always look for the unmet need behind it.
  • Substitution works better than removal: offer a safe, interesting object before or as you redirect the original item.
  • Keep a 'gather basket' of cheap, varied substitutes ready in every room where you spend time.
  • Never yank, argue, or punish — this escalates distress. Use a warm tone and a gentle trade.
  • If grabbing is new or intense, rule out pain, hunger, thirst, or bathroom needs first.
  • Prevention is key: remove tempting items from sight and use environmental setup to reduce triggers.

Why Grabbing Happens in the Amber State

In the amber GEMS state, the brain processes visual information differently. The person is drawn to what they see — a shiny object, a colorful piece of fabric, or even your glasses — because their brain says 'that's interesting, I want it.' They may not recognize that the item belongs to someone else or that grabbing it could cause harm. This is not defiance; it's a primal 'hunt and gather' drive. As Teepa Snow explains, human beings are drawn to what they see or move away from what they don't like, and in dementia, that impulse is magnified because the brain's 'stop and think' filter is weakened.

The Real Need Behind the Grab

Every behavior is a form of communication. A grab might mean 'I'm bored and need something to do with my hands,' 'I'm in pain and I'm trying to get your attention,' or 'I'm anxious and this object feels grounding.' Sometimes it's as simple as 'I see something I like and I want to explore it.' If you immediately take the item away, you may meet resistance, because the person's brain is still locked onto that object. Instead, pause and ask: What is this person trying to accomplish? Are they cold? Hungry? In need of sensory input? Once you identify the unmet need, you can offer a substitute that meets that need safely.

Why Substitution Works Better Than Removal

When you take something away, the person's brain registers a loss — and in dementia, loss can feel like a threat. That can trigger grabbing back, yelling, or even hitting. Substitution works because it honors the impulse: 'You want something in your hands? Here is something safe and interesting.' The key is to offer the substitute before or at the same moment you redirect the original item. You are not saying 'no' — you are saying 'yes, and here's a better option.' This approach reduces agitation and builds trust.

General caregiving information, not medical advice. Check medications and major care changes with your clinician.

Step-by-step

  1. Pause and breathe. Before you react, take one slow breath. Remind yourself: This is the brain, not the person. Your calm presence is the first tool.

  2. Assess the grab. Is the item dangerous (e.g., sharp, hot, breakable)? Is it something precious to you (e.g., your phone, wallet)? Or is it harmless (e.g., a napkin, a magazine)? This tells you how urgently you need to act.

  3. If the item is safe and not precious, let them hold it for a moment. Rushing to take it can escalate. Give them 10-30 seconds to explore — it may satisfy the impulse on its own.

  4. If you need to redirect, have a substitute ready in your hand or nearby. Choose something that mimics the grabbed item: if they grabbed a remote, offer a similar-sized object like a soft ball or a textured fidget toy. If they grabbed your glasses, offer a pair of cheap reading glasses (without lenses) or a bright scarf.

  5. Approach slowly and from the front, not from behind. Say their name softly, then use a warm, low tone: 'I see you found something interesting. Let me trade you for this — feel how soft this is.' Hold the substitute out at eye level, close enough for them to see and reach.

  6. Gently place the substitute into their hand or on the table in front of them. If they resist, don't force it. Instead, set the substitute down nearby and say, 'I'll just leave this here for you.' Then slowly and calmly remove the original item from their line of sight — tuck it into your pocket or behind your back.

  7. If they grab at your body (arm, hair, clothing), do not pull away sharply. Instead, freeze, then offer your other hand with a substitute: 'Here, hold this for me.' A soft cloth, a stress ball, or even a folded towel can work. If they are grabbing because of pain, stop all movement and check for signs of discomfort (see 'discuss with clinician' below).

  8. Once the substitute is accepted, engage them in a simple action with it. Say, 'Can you help me fold this?' or 'Let's see how this feels — is it bumpy or smooth?' This moves the focus from the grab to a shared activity.

  9. If they keep reaching for the original item, do not argue. Simply remove it from the room (out of sight) and offer a new substitute. You may need to repeat this several times. Keep a basket of safe, interesting objects nearby so you always have a backup.

  10. After the moment passes, reflect: Was the grab about boredom? Pain? Hunger? Thirst? Need to use the bathroom? Use this as a clue to prevent future grabs. For example, if they always grab at your phone, keep a dummy phone (old, deactivated) in your pocket to offer preemptively.

What not to do

  • Do not yank the item away. This can trigger a 'fight or flight' response, leading to grabbing back, yelling, or hitting. Instead, use the substitution technique described above.

  • Do not argue or say 'no, that's mine.' Arguing only escalates the behavior because the person cannot process your perspective. Instead, use a neutral, warm tone and redirect.

  • Do not agree with a false belief. If they say 'someone stole my wallet' and they are holding a napkin, do not say 'yes, they stole it.' Instead, say 'I don't see anyone taking it. Let's look together after we finish this.' This avoids reinforcing paranoia.

  • Do not leave expensive or sentimental items within easy reach. Prevention is easier than redirection. Keep your phone, wallet, and jewelry in a zippered pocket or a drawer out of sight.

  • Do not assume the grab is 'bad behavior.' It is always a form of communication. If you punish or scold, you may miss an underlying need like pain, hunger, or fear.

  • Do not use the same substitute every time. Variety keeps the brain engaged. Rotate objects: different textures (soft, bumpy, smooth), colors, and shapes. If they 'mess up' a substitute (e.g., crinkle a magazine), that's okay — it's sensory exploration.

Practical tools

  • The 'Gather Basket'

    Keep a small basket or box filled with safe, interesting objects: a soft scarf, a wooden spoon, a large key ring, a textured ball, a magazine with bright pictures, a piece of fleece fabric. When a grab happens, you can quickly pull out a substitute from the basket. This is especially helpful for repetitive grabbing. You can print a free 'gather tool' checklist from dementiawithgrace.com.

  • The 'Trade and Talk' Script

    Memorize this phrase: 'Oh, you found that! Here, let me show you something else.' Then offer the substitute with a gentle smile. If they resist, try: 'I need your help — can you hold this for me?' This turns the interaction into a collaborative request rather than a confrontation.

  • Sensory Substitutes for Body Grabs

    If the person grabs your arm or hair, keep a 'sensory buffer' nearby — a small stuffed animal, a piece of velvet, or a weighted lap pad. Gently place it between your body and their hand, saying 'Feel this — it's so soft.' This can break the grab without pulling away.

  • The 'Out of Sight, Out of Mind' Setup

    Rearrange the environment to reduce grabbing triggers. Put away clutter, keep countertops clear, and store tempting items (like remote controls or phones) in closed cabinets. Use a tablecloth that matches the table to reduce visual contrast. This reduces the number of 'grabbable' objects in their line of sight.

  • The 'One-Minute Rule' for Precious Items

    If they grab something precious (like your phone), give them one minute to hold it while you prepare a substitute. Say 'Let me just grab something for you' and then trade. This avoids the shock of immediate removal and gives you time to find a good substitute.

  • Pain Check Tool

    If grabbing is new or accompanied by moaning, grimacing, or restlessness, use a pain assessment checklist (like the PAINAD scale, available online). Common causes: arthritis, constipation, urinary tract infection, or ill-fitting shoes. Always discuss persistent pain with a clinician.

Discuss with your clinician

If grabbing is accompanied by new signs of pain (grimacing, moaning, guarding a body part), ask the doctor about a pain assessment and possible medication adjustment.

If the person grabs at their own body (e.g., scratching or pulling at skin), discuss whether this could be a side effect of medication or a sign of skin irritation or infection.

If grabbing leads to falls or injury (e.g., pulling you down), ask the occupational therapist about safe transfer techniques and environmental modifications.

If the person grabs at food or non-food items (pica), discuss with the doctor to rule out nutritional deficiencies or medication side effects.

Related guides

Sources